Lesson: What a Point Is Worth

One class period on mortgage rates: what one percentage point does to a monthly payment, why the Fed can't simply lower the rate, and why so few homeowners sell. For teachers; the student handout is a separate page.

At a glance

Opening hook (5 minutes)

Two buyers, the same $400,000 house, 20% down, a 30-year fixed loan.

Ask: "How much more a month does Buyer B pay?" Take guesses; they usually run low. The answer, from the tool: about $780 a month more, $1,349 against $2,129, and about $280,000 more in interest over the loan.

Reading the chart together (10 minutes)

Project the 30-year mortgage rate chart.

  1. What is it? Freddie Mac's weekly average rate for a 30-year fixed loan, built from mortgage applications lenders send it, for borrowers with good credit and 20% down. The rate was 7.11% in the week ending November 12, 2026, against 6.24% a year earlier.
  2. Compared with what? The 2015–19 average was 4.00%. Click All: the record low was 2.65% (the week ending January 7, 2021) and the record high 18.63% (the week ending October 9, 1981).
  3. What moves it? Under Companion series, tick Mortgage rate minus 10-year yield. A second line shows the gap between the mortgage rate and what the government pays to borrow for ten years. The gap moves, but much less than the rate itself: the mortgage rate rides on the 10-year yield.
  4. Why not the Fed? Read the late-2024 example from What the Mortgage Rate Is: the Fed cut its rate by a full point, the 10-year yield rose by about a point, and mortgage rates went up.

Activity: What a point is worth (20 minutes)

In pairs, using What a Rate Change Does to a Payment. Every case: a $400,000 home, $80,000 down (20%), 30 years.

  1. The ladder. Fill in the monthly payment and the total interest at 3%, 5% and 7%.
  2. One point. At 7%, what does a point lower do to the payment? A point higher?
  3. Same payment, smaller loan. At 5%, read the tool's "the same payment would carry" line: how big a loan does that payment pay off one point higher, at 6%? How much less can the buyer borrow?
  4. Today. Enter this week's rate from the chart. How does today's payment compare with the 2015–19 average rate's?

Exit ticket: "A friend says rates will drop because the Fed is cutting. What would you tell them?"

Discussion questions (10 minutes)

  1. Reading it. Why is Freddie Mac's rate an average for a borrower with good credit and 20% down? Who pays more than it, and why?
  2. In one sentence: what does the mortgage rate follow, if not the Fed?
  3. Placing it. Compare this week's rate with its whole history since 1971, then with 2015–19. Which comparison do buyers feel, and why?
  4. Millions of owners have mortgages below 4%. Why might they stay put instead of moving to a house that suits them better?
  5. Judging it. Some argue the government should help buyers with lower rates, so more of them qualify; others argue that would push prices up. Using the activity, make each case.
  6. Is a 15-year or a 30-year loan the better deal? What does each cost, and what does each give you?

Answer key

Ladder (tool, $320,000 loan, 30 years):

RateMonthly paymentTotal interest
3%$1,349about $165,700
5%$1,718about $298,400
7%$2,129about $446,400

Activity:

Questions:

  1. The average is for borrowers with good credit and 20% down. Lenders charge more for more risk: lower credit scores, smaller down payments, unusual properties. The average is a benchmark, not anyone's quote.
  2. The 10-year Treasury yield, plus a gap that widens when markets are jumpy.
  3. Buyers compare with what friends and parents paid recently, so 2015–19 is the reference they feel, not 1981.
  4. Selling means giving up a low rate for today's, so the same payment buys less house (activity step 3). You Own With a Fixed Mortgage covers this.
  5. For: at a lower rate the same payment carries a bigger loan, so more buyers qualify and owners locked into low rates may finally sell. Against: if more buyers can bid more for the same houses, prices can rise and eat the savings. Which wins depends on how many houses come for sale; What the Mortgage Rate Is gives both arguments.
  6. Neither for everyone: a 15-year loan charges a lower rate and far less interest, but a higher payment. The 30-year keeps the payment lower and leaves room in the budget.

Sources

The weekly digest

One email on Monday mornings: the week's new articles and charts, the numbers that moved most, and what comes out in the week ahead. No ads, and no tracking of opens or clicks.

Past issuesHow addresses are kept